Henry reveals he still has the engagement ring he intended to give his ex-girlfriend Heather before she broke up with him. Larry pressures Henry to sell the ring online to pay for a wine refrigerator, but Henry, ever the hopeless romantic and still holding out hope that Heather is his destiny, doesn't want to sell it. They compromise and agree that if Henry gets an offer equal to what he paid for the ring, Heather wasn't his destiny and he'll sell it. While they wait for bids to come in, Amanda borrows Henry's ring to impress a guy she used to date but hasn't seen in years, and remind him what he gave up by breaking up with her. Meanwhile, the gang is surprised to find out that Tina popped the question to Brad, but has yet to receive a ring from him since they got engaged. Brad gets an idea when he finds out Henry's ring is available, but Tina learns from Amanda that a fake marriage may be much easier than a real one.