Annabeth prosecutes a disgruntled, recently laid-off employee for the murder of one of his colleagues and then learns that his two sons' fingerprints are also on the weapon, raising questions about how to handle the case.

Uncertain as to who actually pulled the trigger, Annabeth wants to gamble and charge the father and his two sons with the murder after cell phone records place all three men near the scene of the crime, leaving it up to the jury to decide. Meanwhile, Maureen and Conlon worry that Annabeth is taking this case too personally, seeking the justice for the victim's wife that she was denied in her husband's murder.