When an odd man wanders into Woody's (Jerry O'Connell) office and claims there has been a murder, Woody and Jordan (Jill Hennessy) learn that the man is the one that was murdered. The man reveals that he was given a slow acting poison that will inevitably kill him. His only request is to find his missing daughter before he dies and Jordan and Woody agree to help. Nigel (Steve Valentine) and Kate (Brooke Smith) team up to solve the murder of two magicians that have seemingly killed each other. Bug (Ravi Kapoor) makes a decision that will change Lily's (Kathryn Hahn) and his lives.