With karma back on his side, Earl (Jason Lee) is approached by the jail warden (Craig T. Nelson) to help resolve one of the biggest problems going on in the jail yard. There are feuding gangs constantly breaking out into fights, and Earl is asked to resolve these gangs' differences. If he is able to settle this conflict, he will receive a lesser sentence. Earl accepts the task and finds out a lot more than he bargained for. Meanwhile, Randy (Ethan Suplee) is still suffering from Earl withdrawals and continues to search for ways to be reunited with his brother.