Eli's visions send him back in time to the day his father (guest star Tom Cavanagh) died, the same week his brother, Nathan, is sued for giving a heart transplant to another patient. But when Nate withholds information that could be detrimental to his case, the flashbacks help Eli to understand the emotional secret his brother has been hiding for years... and give Eli the chance he missed to say goodbye to his father and make amends. Meanwhile, Maggie has an unexpected surprise for Eli, Taylor handles an unusual divorce case in which the husband and wife cheated on each other -- with each other -- and Eli learns that Matt slept with Taylor.