Raja (Adhir Kalyan) befriends an annoying girl named Mindy (guest star Kala Savage, sister of Fred and Ben Savage), feeling that she is unfairly ostracized by the other students. After spending a day studying with her, Raja realizes how truly annoying Mindy can be and is horrified when Justin (Dan Byrd) tells him Mindy believes she and Raja are dating. Trying to let her down gently, Raja tells Mindy they cannot date because of their religious differences. The next day, Mindy shows up in a burka and tells Raja she has converted to Islam so they can be together, forcing Raja to tell her the truth. Meanwhile, Gary (Scott Patterson) and Franny (Amy Pietz) hit it off with the new neighbors Ted (guest star Jim McCauley) and Leslie (guest star April Amber Telek), but are shocked when Ted tells them he must notify all this neighbors that he is a registered sex offender.