In order to make it appear that she has moved on since her break up with Todd, Sam asks Craig (Jerry O'Connell, "Carpoolers," "Crossing Jordan") -- a complete stranger -- to accompany her to Todd's photo gallery exhibit. But Sam soon learns that she may have already crossed paths with Craig at some point in the past, and not in a positive way. Meanwhile, Howard discovers that one of Todd's photos on display features his daughter in a not-so-positive light.

Buy this episode at