Justin (Dan Byrd) notices that Raja (Adhir Kalyan) is obsessed with Sadika Sadaqatmal (guest star Sunita Prasad), one of the few Muslim girls in Medora. When Franny (Amy Pietz) hears about Raja's interest in a girl, she immediately arranges for a date which requires the attendance of every member of the Tolchuck and Sadaqatmal families. Justin is stung when his parents comment that even Raja has begun dating while Justin has yet to find a girlfriend, so he asks out a neurotic girl named Donna (guest star Carol Hodge). Meanwhile, Claire (Lindsey Shaw) begins dating a German exchange student (guest star Larn Anderson) who lives with the Sadaqatmal family.