Jake, fed up with memories of his former fiancée, Annie, intruding into his life, finally decides to get rid of all traces of her. He throws out their old photos and trinkets, erases her last phone message and even donates his fancy suits to charity in hopes of starting fresh.

But things don’t go as planned when Annie suddenly turns up on his doorstep to retrieve the family watch she gave him before they broke up and he realizes he may still have feelings for her – but now she’s engaged to someone else. Meanwhile, new mother Naomi (Malick) makes a shocking discovery:

Once you have a baby, the hospital eventually sends you home with it. She leans on Jake for support in coping with her newborn son. And Patrick has some news of his own: He’s going to open up a bakery called “Muffin” that sells nothing but cupcakes.