Steven assumes that since he and Lizzie slept together, he will now be her boyfriend. Lloyd tries to tell him that that's not always the way it works, but Steven doesn't want to listen. Eventually Steven learns from Lizzie that it was indeed a fling, because she has a boyfriend. Steven is determined to win her back, and asks her to the movie showing of "American Pie" on campus. Will he be able to convince her that he's the one for her?